Pumpkin Pie Coffee Cake

November 9, 2013 in Categories: , by

Print Friendly

I have a new favorite paleo flour: chestnut flour.  I bought some just to play with it and it’s amazing!  It’s very fine (like all purpose flour fine) and yields a wonderful texture in baking with a nice subtle flavor.  It’s more like wheat flour than any other nut flour I’ve tried (doesn’t bind quite as well as wheat flour but a little better than almond flour).  I think you’ll be seeing a lot more recipes featuring chestnut flour from me in the future.

Pumpkin Pie Coffee Cake | The Paleo MomThis recipe started as a revamp of my pumpkin pie squares.  I’ve been slowly going through some of my older baking recipes that use a lot of flax and tinker with them to get rid of the flax seed.  I’m not opposed to using flax when there really are no other options in terms of baking chemistry and we’re talking about an occasional treat…. but if I can make it flax-free, that’s what I would prefer health wise (now that I know that flax is crazy high in phytoestrogens).  Since I was also in a playing with chestnut flour mood and then had this idea that I wanted pieces of walnuts in the squares and then decided to increase the recipe by 50%… well, one thing led to another, and before I knew it, I was baking my squares in a tube pan.  So, this recipe is sort-of a revamp (in the sense that it’s a cakey thing with a pumpkin pie flavor)–and I’m sure you could make squares if you baked this in a greased 9″ x 13″ pan (omit the walnuts to be closer to the original recipe)– but, really, this recipe has evolved enough that it stands on it’s own as Pumpkin Pie Coffee Cake.

I made my own pumpkin puree for this cake, although you could use canned too.  My favorite way to make pumpkin puree is to take a pie pumpkin (or two or six), pierce a few times with a knife, place in a 350F oven and bake for 1 hour (or more if your pumpkins are on the larger side).  Let cool enough to handle.  Cut in half, easily scoop out the seeds, then scoop out the pumpkin flesh or peel the peel right off…  Very easy and you get a nice thick puree (especially compared to boiling or steaming).

I’ve also made a recent discovery:  Pure Indian Foods Organic Cultured Grass-fed Ghee.  The culturing degrades the casein before clarifying, and compared to regular ghee which does contain trace casein, this has none.  Even my SUPER sensitive younger daughter can eat this (and she can’t eat a piece of fruit that was cut on a board that cheese was cut on and then rinsed rather than sterilized).  I’ve been enjoying it myself and love the flavor in baking!  You could substitute regular ghee or butter too, or even palm shortening or lard.

Yield: one coffee cake

Pumpkin Pie Coffee Cake | The Paleo MomIngredients:

  1. Preheat oven to 350F.  Grease a tube pan (or bundt pan) with ghee, butter or coconut oil or use a silicone pan.
  2. Combine all ingredients except the chopped walnuts in a blender and process until smooth (yes, it is that easy).
  3. Fold in chopped nuts.  Pour into prepared pan and bake for 40 minutes (or until it passes the toothpick test).

Notes:  In a loaf pan, this recipe took 55 minutes to cook through.  You can also turn these into some pretty awesome muffins, which only take 20 minutes to bake.

I also made a version of these where I folded in half a cup of chocolate chips in addition to the walnuts.  REALLY YUM.

I also made a version of these where I folded in half a cup of chocolate chips in addition to the walnuts. REALLY YUM.

Substitutions:  I often get asked about substitutions, and this is a challenging question to answer because, believe it or not, I don’t try every possible permutation of ingredients for every recipe.  This recipe works wonderfully (I’ve made it three times!).  I think you could sub almond flour for chestnut flour, but you might need an extra quarter or half cup because it’s not as fine.  I think you could substitute arrowroot for tapioca.  Yes, you might be able to use an egg replacer in this recipe.  If you want to play with subbing coconut flour, you’ll need at least 1/2 cup of whatever you choose.  I’m confident that you could use lard or palm shortening instead of ghee or butter.  I think coconut oil or even avocado oil would work too.  You can definitely sub pumpkin pie spice or your favorite spice blend for the seasoning I list here.  You can omit the walnuts or sub any chopped nut you like.


This is so awesome! I haven’t been able to bake since starting the Paleo lifestyle as the idea of almonds, almonds, almonds just makes my body cringe. Chestnut flour, though, that is exciting! I feel great about this recipe. After reading more about chestnut flour, I cannot wait to start trying it out. Thank you!

Also, has the Paleo world ever thought of using acorn flour? After all, it was the staple for most Native American tribes in California…There are so many acorns that just sit on the ground and decompose. I figured you of all people would know…

I made this cake today and it is delicious!! Great light texture. I followed the recipe except for replacing tapioca with arrowroot, which worked great. We don’t eat nuts so I used mini chocolate chunks instead. What a treat! I made it in a bundt pan and it baked in exactly the amount of time specified. Thank you so much for this recipe! Now I have something besides crepes to make with my chestnut flour!

I have bought chestnut flour in QLD, Australia. I think Flannery’s and some other organic supplies (eg. Kunara) and some health food shops have it.

is this AIP, besides the eggs? will love to make it but right now i am having very bad flare ups and don’t know if i should use eggs. Boo Hoo!

Hi there! I think something went wrong with mine.. It stays wet on the inside, even after one hour of baking. I used the same measurements, but added homemade pumpkin puree. Should I use less? Help? 🙂

Hooray – probably a year ago, I saw a recipe that called for chestnut flour. I finally found it on Amazon – locally there was none to be found. So, I am going to get on this new recipe of yours, pronto. BTW – the substitutions that you detail are very appreciated! I’ve been on your subscriber list for some time now – and always appreciate you! Thank you!

Made this “coffee cake” last night – came out ok – for me the spices were a bit much (for my lady friend) – so I’d probably back off some of them or just switch over to pumpkin pie spice with one other? Anyway, gathering all that stuff up and the measuring etc – was lengthy – including finding my sifter to sift the dry ingredients/flour. One last thing, using the blender was a chore. And, its hard to scrape it all out too. Can I get the same good “blend” with a food processor? So, I will also think about maybe a “light” frosting too. But just as is – is great too!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *