Is Oxalate Sensitivity Real?

Oxalate is a type of organic acid salt that occurs naturally in many plant foods, and can also be produced endogenously (within our bodies) from the metabolism of vitamin C, glycine, glycolate, or hydroxyproline. A number of nutrient-dense, Paleo-friendly foods are high in oxalate, including a variety of leafy greens (beet greens, spinach, chard, endive, dandelion greens, kale, purslane, watercress, turnip greens, and collard greens!), most berries, most nuts, tea (made from real tea leaves), sweet potatoes, white potatoes, chives, parsley, broccoli, cabbage, okra, chocolate, beet root, cassava, carrots, and rhubarb. For the average American, three foods alone—spinach, potatoes, and nuts—make up 44% of our total oxalate intake!

Unfortunately, many people have been scared away from eating high-oxalate foods due to concerns about oxalate sensitivity. Although there’s no official medical definition for oxalate sensitivity, it typically refers to a tendency to develop kidney stones and/or muscle and joint pain as a result of eating high-oxalate foods. When the concentration of oxalates and calcium in the urine becomes too high to dilute (a condition called hyperoxaluria), calcium oxalate crystals can form in the kidneys and develop into stones (although there are different types of kidney stones, calcium-oxalate kidney stones are the most common, accounting for about 80% of cases!). When oxalate levels are too high in the blood (a condition called oxalosis), oxalate crystals can build up in the joints, muscles, and other tissues, leading to oxalate arthritis.

To be clear, hyperoxularia and oxalosis are legitimate conditions—there’s no controversy there. Some people (about one in three million) have genetic disorders that cause too much oxalate to be produced within the body, and other people have absorption disorders that cause too much oxalate to get absorbed from the gut (including Crohn’s disease, celiac disease, chronic pancreatitis, and side-effects from bariatric surgery). The question is whether high-oxalate foods are to blame for the symptoms that result, and whether cutting those foods out of our diet is really the best plan of action. And, the answers aren’t so simple!

---

The AIP 2020 Summit!!

The first-ever summit devoted entirely to the Autoimmune Protocol will cover everything from “AIP 101” basics and cooking demos to deep dives into complementary treatments, scientific advances and medical studies, and practices that bridge the mind and spirit with the body for healing.
 
Get actionable and practical tips from experienced AIP coaches and leaders.
 
Don’t miss this online educational summit from January 6-12, 2020.

Save your seat for free!

---

Oxalates from Food

Part of the problem with avoiding high-oxalate foods in order to treat “oxalate sensitivity” is that the oxalate we eat doesn’t automatically become oxalate in our blood and urine. In fact, the relationship between oxalate in our diets, the oxalate in our bodies, and the formation of oxalate stones is far from linear. Studies of specific foods show that high-oxalate items don’t increase urinary oxalate in a proportional manner (in other words, the amount of oxalate in a food doesn’t always predict how much oxalate will show up in the urine after that food is eaten). For example, almonds and black beans are both high in oxalate, but trials using these foods show that a significantly higher portion of oxalate is absorbed from almonds than from black beans. Another study found that among high-oxalate foods, only eight (spinach, nuts, beets, rhubarb, tea, chocolate, strawberries, and wheat bran) significantly increased the amount of oxalate excreted through the urine. And, some high-oxalate foods (such as green tea) have been shown to protect against the formation of kidney stones, most likely due to their antioxidative components. A 2008 study concluded that “For many stone formers, restricting dietary oxalate may be a relatively ineffective intervention to reduce urinary oxalate excretion.”

How could this be? There are a few explanations! Under normal circumstances, the body has mechanisms to maintain oxalate homeostasis regardless of how much oxalate we ingest. In the gut, the bacteria Oxalobacter formigenes (as well as some lactobacilli and bifidobacteria strains, particularly Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis) degrades oxalate from the foods we eat, and helps regulate how much dietary oxalate makes it into our system. And on top of reducing absorption, O. formigenes also stimulates the intestinal epithelium to secrete oxalate that’s already within our bodies, which helps reduce our total oxalate load even further! Research shows that people with oxalate-degrading bacteria in their guts have significantly lower risk of developing kidney stones, even on high-oxalate diets (for example, people colonized with O. formigenes have a 70% lower risk of being recurrent kidney stone formers). And, studies have also demonstrated that consuming oxalate-degrading bacteria (such lactic acid bacteria including B. infantis, L. plantarum, and L. brevis) reduces oxalate levels in urine, meaning that certain probiotics could help combat kidney stones and other problems associated with high oxalate levels.

On top of that, a number of dietary factors (independent of any gut conditions we have, like celiac or Crohn’s disease) influence how much oxalate we absorb from food, whether our urine will become oversaturated with oxalate, and whether we’ll develop kidney stones. For example:

• Dehydration is a major cause of high urinary oxalate and kidney stone development. Increasing fluid intake (hydrating ourselves better!) reduces the risk of kidney stones by increasing urine volume and diluting calcium and oxalate levels, in turn helping prevent stones from forming. In fact, ingesting enough fluids (whether through drinking beverages or eating high-water-volume foods like vegetables and fruit) to keep urine flow greater than 1 ml/kg/h nearly eliminates the risk of oxalate oversaturation in the urine, and can dramatically reduce kidney stone formation!
• Although calcium supplements have been positively associated with kidney stones, too little dietary calcium can also increase our risk of kidney stones. That’s because dietary calcium reduces how much oxalate we absorb, leading to lower oxalate levels in the urine (so when we consume inadequate calcium, oxalate levels can concurrently rise). The key here is to avoid both extremely high and extremely low intakes of calcium, sticking instead to diverse nutrient-dense foods that supply healthy amounts of this mineral (think: bone-in fish like sardines, dark leafy greens, broccoli, and high-quality dairy for those who tolerate it).
• Citric acid, found at high concentrations in citrus fruits (especially lemons and limes), has been shown to protect against kidney stones by binding with urinary calcium (which helps prevent urine from becoming oversaturated with calcium) and by binding with calcium oxalate crystals (which prevents the crystals from growing in size and becoming stones). Consuming 4 oz. of lemon juice per day is enough to increase levels of urinary citrate (citrates are citric acid salts) and reduce kidney stone risk. Cranberry juice appears to have a similar kidney stone-reducing properties, by reducing both oxalate and calcium levels in the urine while boosting urinary citrate levels.
• Because of its conversion to oxalate in the body, vitamin C intake can influence oxalate levels in our urine, and—at high intakes—potentially contribute to stones. Although there’s no need to stop eating whole-food, nutrient-dense sources of vitamin C (like citrus fruit and other fresh produce), people prone to kidney stones could benefit from avoiding vitamin C supplements.

Oxalate Sensitivity… or Histamine and Salicylate Intolerance?

Oxalate sensitivity is frequently self-diagnosed based on observed symptoms when eating high-oxalate foods. However, most of the time, this is probably a case of mistaken identity!

While it’s true that many people feel better after switching to a low-oxalate diet (at least anecdotally!), many high-oxalate foods are also rich in two other problematic compounds: histamine and salicylate (see “Teaser Excerpt from The Paleo Approach: Histamine Intolerance” and “What is Salicylate Sensitivity/Intolerance?”). In fact, some of the highest-oxalate foods are also high in histamine (spinach, strawberries, and tea), and the vast majority of high-oxalate foods are also high in salicylate, including: berries, broccoli, coffee, tea, sweet potatoes, beets, carrots white potatoes, spinach, carrots, and almonds!

Because of the tremendous overlap between foods containing oxalate, histamine, and salicylate, it’s likely that some people who feel better eating a low-oxalate diet are actually improving because they’ve reduced their histamine and/or salicylate intake. This is particularly true if the symptoms that clear up on a low-oxalate diet are unrelated to arthritis or kidney stones, which are the only issues credibly linked to oxalate (for example: headaches, itchy skin, hives, rashes, fatigue, nasal congestion, itchy or puffy eyes, hives, rashes, and other allergy-like symptoms are unrelated to oxalate, but definitely could result from histamine and salicylate intolerance!). So, “oxalate sensitivity” may be a case of mistaken identity in many instances.

But Isn’t Oxalate an Antinutrient?

Like phytate, oxalate is a salt, meaning that it’s a mineral (most notably calcium) bound with oxalic acid.  There’s an erroneous myth that eating foods high in oxalates (or phytates) will deplete our bodies of important minerals, but this is simply not true.  While oxalate (and phytate) make the minerals that it’s bound to within the food we eat more difficult to absorb (at least until they’re properly processed by our healthy gut bacteria), they do not leach minerals from our bodies.  It’s also a myth that we can’t absorb any nutrition from foods rich in oxalates (or phytates); not only can our gut bacteria liberate the minerals from these antinutrients, these foods contain vitamins, fiber, phytochemicals and minerals that are not bound with oxalic or phytic acid which are all beneficial!

Should We Avoid High-Oxalate Foods?

So, should we limit our intake of high-oxalate foods in order to improve our health? For most of us, the answer is a resounding no!  For people who have never developed kidney stones or oxalate-related muscle and joint pain, oxalate consumption is generally a non-issue. On the other hand, people with gut disorders (or other medical conditions) that increase oxalate absorption might initially benefit from cutting back on high-oxalate foods, but unless the condition is due to an unchangeable genetic defect, this is just putting a Band-Aid on the real problem. Rather than eliminating some of the most nutrient-dense foods on the planet, our focus should be on building a healthy gut microbiome that adequately degrades oxalate and prevents excess oxalate from getting absorbed (while also making an effort to stay fully hydrated, consuming sources of citric acid, and eating a diet with sufficient (but not excessive) calcium). These changes may (over time!) enable the small number of people with legitimate “oxalate sensitivity” to consume high-oxalate foods without negative consequences.

Citations

Campier C, et al. “Reduction of oxaluria after an oral course of lactic acid bacteria at high concentration.” Kidney Int. 2001 Sep;60(3):1097-105.

Chai W & Liebman M. “Assessment of oxalate absorption from almonds and black beans with and without the use of an extrinsic label.” J Urol. 2004 Sep;172(3):953-7.

Dogliotti E, et al. “Nutrition in calcium nephrolithiasis.” J Transl Med. 2013;11:109.

Ito Y, et al. “Preventive Effects of Green Tea on Renal Stone Formation and the Role of Oxidative Stress in Nephrolithiasis.” J Urol. 2005;173(1):271-275.

Jeong BC, et al. “Effects of green tea on urinary stone formation: an in vivo and in vitro study.” J Endourol. 2006 May;20(5):356-61.

Jiang J, et al. “Impact of dietary calcium and oxalate, and Oxalobacter formigenes colonization on urinary oxalate excretion.” J Urol. 2011 Jul;186(1):135-9. doi: 10.1016/j.juro.2011.03.006. Epub 2011 May 14.

Johnri N, et al. “An update and practical guide to renal stone management.” Nephron Clin Pract. 2010;116(3):c159-71. doi: 10.1159/000317196. Epub 2010 Jul 2.

Kaufman DW, et al. “Oxalobacter formigenes May Reduce the Risk of Calcium Oxalate Kidney Stones.” J Am Soc Nephrol. 2008 Jun; 19(6): 1197–1203.

Klimesova K, et al. “Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis decreases urinary oxalate excretion in a mouse model of primary hyperoxaluria.” Urolithiasis. 2015;43(2):107-117.

Knight J, et al. “Ascorbic acid intake and oxalate synthesis.” Urolithiasis. 2016 Aug;44(4):289-97.

Li X, et al. “Oxalobacter formigenes Colonization and Oxalate Dynamics in a Mouse Model.” Appl Environ Microbiol. 2015 Aug;81(15):5048-54.

Lies JC, et al. “Use of a probiotic to decrease enteric hyperoxaluria.” Kidney Int. 2005 Sep;68(3):1244-9.

Lorenz E, et al. “Update on Oxalate Crystal Disease.” Curr Rheumatol Rep. 2013 Jul; 15(7): 340.

Luck A, et al. “Human serum transferrin: Is there a link between autism, high oxalate and iron deficiency anemia?” Biochemistry. 2013 Nov 19; 52(46): 10.1021/bi401190m.

Massey LK, et al. “Effect of dietary oxalate and calcium on urinary oxalate and risk of formation of calcium oxalate kidney stones.” J Am Diet Assoc. 1993 Aug;93(8):901-6.

Saxena A & Sharma RK. “Nutritional aspect of nephrolithiasis.” Indian J Urol. 2010 Oct;26(4):523-30.

Seltzer MA, et al. “Dietary manipulation with lemonade to treat hypocitraturic calcium nephrolithiasis.” J Urol. 1996 Sep;156(3):907-9.

Stewart CS, et al. “Oxalobacter formigenes and its role in oxalate metabolism in the human gut.” FEMS Microbiol Lett. 2004 Jan 15;230(1):1-7.

Taylor EN & Curhan GC. “Determinants of 24-hour Urinary Oxalate Excretion.” Clin J Am Soc Nephrol. 2008 Sep; 3(5): 1453–1460.

Traxer O, et al. “Effect of ascorbic acid consumption on urinary stone risk factors.” J Urol. 2003 Aug;170(2 Pt 1):397-401.

Turroni S, et al. “Oxalate-Degrading Activity in Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis: Impact of Acidic Conditions on the Transcriptional Levels of the Oxalyl Coenzyme A (CoA) Decarboxylase and Formyl-CoA Transferase Genes.” Applied and Environmental Microbiology. 2010;76(16):5609-5620.