This simple vegetable dish is so versatile. I find myself making a version of this often (I especially enjoy it beside pork!), in part because it’s quick to put together and bakes relatively quickly (especially compared to other root vegetables). I also love that I can throw it in the oven at whatever temperature my meat is cooking and it seems to always work out. And what better way to ring in the fall than with these iconic fall flavors!
I’m on a plantain kick these days. If you can’t find green plantains (or can’t handle how starchy they are), simply omit them (you can add a little more squash and/or a little more apple). I also love butternut squash, but you could use acorn squash, fresh pumpkin or any other winter squash you can get your hands on (or a mix of a couple of varieties). Good apple varieties for cooking are granny smith, rome beauty, mutsu/crispin and fuji.
Cinnamon Butternut Squash and Plantain with Apple
Prep
Cook
Total
Yield 5-6 servings
Ingredients
- 1 ½ pounds butternut squash
- 1 large green plantain
- 1 large (or 2 medium) apple
- 2 Tbsp coconut oil (this is also delicious with red palm oil or bacon fat)
- ½ tsp cinnamon
- salt to taste
Instructions
- Peel and seed squash. Cut into slightly smaller than 1” cubes.
- Cut plantain lengthwise in half and remove peel. Cut into ½” thick semi-circles.
- Peel and core apple and cut into ½” cubes.
- Toss squash, plantain and apple with melted coconut oil and cinnamon. Place in a 9×9” baking dish.
- Bake in the oven until tender. At 350F, it takes 30 minutes to cook. At 375F, it takes 20 minutes to cook. At 425F, it takes 10 minutes to cook.
Watch this video from my YouTube Channel to learn more about green plantains:

The #1 Tool for Paleo and AIP success!
Create completely customizable and versatile meal plans with thousands of top-notch recipes; make shopping a breeze with the app, and even get reminders for meal prep timing! Get all my recipes from ThePaleoMom.com for just $1 more when you sign up for meal planning with Real Plans!
Want to track what you are eating? Check out the NEW Real Plans Macro Tracker!
You may enjoy these related posts:
Roasted Butternut Squash
This roasted butternut squash is so simple to prepare, it feels like cheating …
Maple-Braised Butternut Squash
I discovered this wonderful way of cooking butternut squash one evening when my …
Cinnamon-Braised Beef Cheek
When my local farmer offered me 25 pounds of grass-fed beef cheek for a mere …
Meatball and Winter Squash Casserole
Winter squash is coming into season and there’s something about this delightful …
Plantain and Apple Fritters
The Paleo Approach Cookbook has been on bookshelves for not quite three weeks …
Bacon-Wrapped Spiced Pumpkin
I was honored to be invited to participate in this year’s Healthy Virtual …
Paleo Apple Crisp
I started playing with apple crisp recipes before I ever started the blog. It …
Apple “Oat” Muffins
When our family went to pick apples at a local apple orchard this year, we made …
Puerto Rican-Inspired Green Plantain Mash (Mofongo)
Mofongo is a traditional fried plantain-based dish from Puerto Rico. It is …
Spinach Brownies Revisited (Now It’s Nut-Free!)
I haven’t made these brownies in a very long time; but over the weekend, I found …
Mulled Apple-Braised Pork Shank
When I bought half of a pastured pig from my local farmer this winter, I was …
Paleo Baby Foods–What to Introduce When
You can absolutely start your baby off right by feeding them Paleolithic foods, …