Gluten-Free in the News (some Yay! some Nay!)

February 6, 2013 in Paleo Philosophy

Two news stories centered around gluten-free diets were published in the New York Times in the last week, one the magazine section and one in the science/health section.  I’d like to take this opportunity to give a huge shout-out to the NYT for having staff science writers (who actually have science backgrounds!).  So few media outlets have science reporters any more and I believe this is one of the biggest hurdles we face as a society in battling the enormous amount of misinformation out there.  There is a need for people with science backgrounds and a talent for distilling and explaining science to report on it in the media.  There’s a need, but there’s no money–most media outlets aren’t hiring.

03arthritis1-articleLarge-v2The first story The Boy With a Thorn in His Joints was published February 1st.  It excited many people with its explanation of the link between gut health (and specifically a leaky gut) and inflammation.  It shares the story of a 5-year old boy named Sheperd, diagnosed with the intensely painful autoimmune disease juvenile idiopathic arthritis at 3-years old, who found no answers with conventional medicine (either NSAIDs or DMARDs).  The story is told by Shepherd’s mother and her reports of interactions with her son’s pediatric rheumatologist make me angry.  I had similar experiences with my daughter’s pediatric gastroenterologist (one of the top in the country) who thought that putting my daughter on a dairy-free, gluten-free diet  was nonsense (and yet is cured her of her obstructive sleep apnea, so there!).

Shepherd’s parents finally hit a desperate point where they were willing to try “complimentary medicine” approaches.  They switched Sheperd to a gluten-free, dairy-free, nightshade-free and refined sugar-free diet in conjunction with supplements including fish oil, probiotics, sour Montmorency cherry juice and a Chinese herbal supplement called four-marvels powder.    In 6 weeks, Shepherd starting recovering, feeling less pain and having more mobility.  Not long afterward, they were able to wean him off of DMARDs and now report that the only times that Shepherd has had flares in the last year is after accidentally eating gluten or needing to go on antibiotics.

This story is powerful.  Emotional and triumphant.   The agony of waiting for something to work for six whole weeks, not knowing if it will, the stress the anxiety are palpable.   The sheer joy at being able to “fix” your child’s problem, but with always that seed of doubt of whether it will return, hit home.   And the explanation that arthritis is caused by a leaky gut which causes inflammation and stimulates the immune system  is a very good one.   I have no doubt that there are many families now researching gluten-free, dairy-free diets for their children.  Maybe some of the will take that small extra step and try a paleo diet.

05well_gluten-tmagArticleThe second story Gluten-Free, Whether You Need It or Not, published February 6th, presents the mystery and controversy around gluten sensitivity.  The controversy is really one of definition.  It is now being recognized that there exists celiac disease, wheat allergy, gluten intolerance and gluten sensitivity.  This paper in the very high impact research journal Gut (I always did love that name) suggests using the term “gluten-related disorders” as an umbrella term for all of these related but disparate conditions.  The problem is that gluten sensitivity is not well defined or well understood (hence the mystery).  There are medical professionals at both ends of the extreme, those that say it doesn’t exist versus those that claim that most people are actually gluten sensitive because humans are not adapted to digesting grains.

The article explains some very important points.  The incidence of celiac disease is increasing.  This might be because GMO grains contain more gluten.  The vast majority of celiacs remain undiagnosed.   Those who have gluten sensitivity are simply those who feel better when they follow a gluten-free diet (there is no test).  There is research showing that people with Irritable Bowel Syndrome felt better and had fewer symptoms when following a gluten-free diet (in a very cleverly designed blinded trial).  This is important information to be out there in the mainstream media!

 But, I felt irked as I read this article.  It was written by one of the NYT’s staff science writers, Kenneth Chang, who does a good job of presenting most of the many sides to this issue.  But not all the sides.  Maybe I was feeling overly defensive, being obviously part of one of the fringe and fad extremes that the article presents, but I took issue with a few statements in this article..

The article gives an anecdotal example of a women who lost weight and had her allergies go away after adopting a gluten-free diet.  The article then goes on to explain that experts are skeptical.  Quote:  “It does not make obvious sense, for example, that someone would lose weight on a gluten-free diet. In fact, the opposite often happens for celiac patients as their malfunctioning intestines recover.”  Can I jump in here?  Celiacs gain weight when their intestines recover because they can finally absorb nutrients from their food.  People who are gluten sensitive but non-celiac often lose weight when they remove gluten from their diet because they are reducing inflammation, regulating hormones, and cutting out a major source of nutrient-poor sugar-rich foods.  It actually makes total sense.

Two other statements just riled me, both implying that gluten-free diets are less healthy and so people who aren’t diagnosed with gluten-related disorders should not adopt gluten-free diets.  The first statement is a quote from Dr. Stefano Guandalini, medical director of the University of Chicago’s Celiac Disease Center.  “It is not a healthier diet for those who don’t need it,” Dr. Guandalini said. These people “are following a fad, essentially.” He added, “And that’s my biased opinion.”  Yes, that is a biased opinion.  And in my biased opinion, it’s an uninformed one.  The second irksome statement:  “They [experts] also worried that people could end up eating less healthfully. A gluten-free muffin generally contains less fiber than a wheat-based one and still offers the same nutritional dangers — fat and sugar. Gluten-free foods are also less likely to be fortified with vitamins.”

Can I jump in again?  Okay, yes, I obviously think that the vast majority of gluten-free baked goods available are not healthy.  They tend to still be grain-based and loaded with emulsifiers.  Clearly, I do not believe in simply substituting wheat with rice and corn.  But, how about those of us who choose to replace gluten-containing foods with vegetables!?  I don’t need to remind you about how much healthier vegetables are than any grain, do I?  I don’t need to say that vegetables contain more of every single micronutrient than grains, for a fraction of the sugar and at least the same amount of fiber, do I?  The same can even be said of fruit, although fruit is somewhere in the middle in terms of sugar content.  And while people who eat gluten-free (and not paleo) typically do buy some gluten-free breads and pastas, they also typically consume fewer of these types of products than people eating the Standard American Diet.  So while gluten-free baked goods might not be fortified, you can’t judge an entire diet based on them.  Yes, I’m sure there are gluten-free folks out there chowing down on empty sugary gluten-free junk and who really are eating a less healthy diet.  But, to label gluten-free as less healthy is wrong.  Cutting gluten out of your diet does not deprive you of any nutrients.  I suppose I could also mention that whole vilification of fat thing here too.  But, it’s late.  So, I’ll summarize:  fat is not bad for you.  Sheesh.

I’m sure someone else reading the story would have focused more on the other positive aspects.  Gluten-free in the news is good.  Explaining that it’s a spectrum and that it’s not just celiac is good.  Encouraging people to have a dialogue with their doctors is good.  It’s just hard for me to gloss over the fact that this article put big warning signs on gluten-free diets like somehow cutting gluten our of your diet might deprive you of vital nutrition.  Did I already say sheesh?

Let’s end on a positive note though.  Paleo is gaining momentum and, while many still consider it a fad diet, the scientific basis behind it is providing traction.  More and more, people are healing themselves by changing how they eat.  More and more, wonderful success stories like Shepherd’s stories are making headlines.   And it’s very exciting to watch people take back their health!

Real People, Real Paleo—Jolaine’s Story (and how difficult getting an accurate diagnosis can be-part2)

December 19, 2012 in Living with Autoimmune Disease, Real People, Real Paleo

“Real People, Real Paleo” is a series of posts written by real people who were inspired to share their paleo story with you.  There is such diversity in the challenges that bring us to a paleo diet and lifestyle and in what we hope to achieve by adopting them.  These stories are intended to be a place of inspiration, written by real people, showing the diversity of our needs and our approaches to this way of eating and living, and explaining how each individual’s implementation of paleo meets their needs.  By sharing these people’s stories with you on my blog, I hope to redefine what paleo success is.  I do not believe that eating paleo is purely about losing weight, gaining muscle, and having 6-pack abs.  I believe that paleo is about being healthy enough to thoroughly enjoy life, whatever that means for you, and about sustainability for our entire lives.  If you are interested in writing up your story, email me at thepaleomommy@gmail.com

So, I’m not in the habit of commenting on stories written for my Real People, Real Paleo series.  My preference is to let these stories speak for themselves.  But, I wanted introduce Jolaine’s Story with some amazing (and horrifying) statistics.  Autoimmune disease can be challenging to diagnose because it often presents as a collection of vague symptoms (such as fatigue, headaches, and muscle or joint aches).  Too often these symptoms are dismissed as signs of not getting enough rest, working too hard, life being too stressful, being over- or underweight, or our bodies just getting older.  What’s more, because there are no “autoimmune specialists”, we see doctors who don’t necessarily have the appropriate training to accurately diagnose these diseases (instead we see specialists in the organ or system that is showing the most symptoms).  A survey performed by the American Autoimmune and Related Diseases Association, Inc. (AARDA) showed that the majority of patients later diagnosed with serious autoimmune conditions had a difficult time obtaining a diagnosis.  In fact, 45 percent of these patients were labeled as hypochondriacs in the earliest stages of their illnesses.  Jolaine and I have had several back and forths via e-mail (and facebook and pinterest!) and I asked Jolaine to share her story because I believe it will resonate with many of you.  And I hope that by sharing Jolaine’s decades-long battles with undiagnosed autoimmune disease, that someone out there will have a lightbulb moment and will be armed with knowledge and confidence to request the right diagnostic tests from the right specialists and finally find their answers.

This is part 2 of 2. Read part 1 here.

 So, about two years ago the beginning of finding the answer began, although at the time I didn’t know it.  I was having considerable amount of pain in my feet, so naturally my doctor suggested a podiatrist.  A little funny tidbit it that his name was Dr. Schumacher!  For those who have zero German knowledge, that means shoemaker. J  He was a really kind fella and found that surgery may indeed be helpful, but that depends on how well I heal.  He asked me series of questions regarding my medical history and it didn’t take long to realize that inflammation could be a huge factor and be a hindrance in healing well.  He was curious, which I like because so am I, and wanted to do some blood tests just to see what we would find.  Sure enough, my rheumatoid markers were slightly elevated, and I had tested positive for a gene called HLAB27.  A small little bell went off in my head and it sounded familiar.  My oldest sister with Crohn’s disease also had tested positive, as had my Mom.  He suggested that perhaps in the next few years I should see a rheumatologist and follow up on the rheumatoid tests just to watch my inflammation levels.  Well okay.  I filed that away in my catalogue of things to do, and not anxious to make yet another Dr’s appointment.  Not long after that, a friend on Facebook posted a very unusual comment saying “I am HLAB27 negative”.  Odd, but I understood so I sent her a private message asking why she was tested, and that I’m positive for the gene.  She responded asking if I have AS.  I didn’t know what that was, so I quickly went to Google and read the symptoms.  I just knew, deep down more than I ever knew that I did have AS. Every single random symptom was a part of my life.  Facebook is good for something after all!  I insisted on a referral to a rheumatologist, and waited another 9 months to get an appointment.  My physiotherapist, chiropractor and naturopath all didn’t think it was likely that I’d get a positive diagnosis.  When I saw the specialist the first time, he did his usual physical test.  Bend, twist, reach, poke here and there, does this hurt, can you take a deep breath and determined it seemed highly unlikely.  And then, for the first time a doctor looked me in the eyes and said; “but I believe what you are telling me about your pain” and he took into consideration my blood tests and family history.  He ordered an x-ray and there it was, my diagnosis.  Ankylosing spondylitis.  My constant companion.

Many would say it’s good to have a diagnosis now.  Now you can move on.  At first I agreed with that thought, but I quickly learned it was not all good.  Having that diagnosis removed my hope that maybe it will be gone one day.  Just a little tweek, the missing puzzle piece, and I’ll be back to my old self again.  If I could remember what my old self was exactly that would be helpful.  The bright side is that now, when people say “what’s wrong” I don’t give a long list of symptoms and feel like an idiot.  It’s a disease they’ve never heard of and that seems legit enough to appease them.  The bright side is now I know where to focus my investigation of learning and healing.  The down side is I still have pain and the losses are not recoverable or measureable.  The down side is, the medical community still doesn’t get it.  I still struggle to get treated like an intelligent adult woman with choices in my own care.  I’ve been prescribed many drugs since my diagnosis followed with “if you don’t follow my advice and prescriptions I will no longer be able to be your doctor”.  I agreed to try each of them for 2 weeks, and each time I go into a flare up of immobility and pain that takes your breath away.  The longest of these flares this year was ten weeks nearly complete immobility, after which I needed to pretty much learn to walk again.  As I write this, I’m again in this same position.

The biggest bright side is during those ten weeks this summer, I came across the paleo lifestyle and diet.  I soaked up every bit of information I could find.  I had previously seen the video of Dr. Terry Wahls and her journey with paleo and healing from MS, but that was before my diagnosis and for some reason that didn’t stick as something I needed to know.  I instead passed it on to my youngest sister with MS and left it at that.  When I look back now I see little pieces of the puzzle I should have picked up on, and can only explain it as I was simply just exhausted and trying to survive. So for those ten weeks I read for hours and hours on my smart phone through the days and nights while lying in bed.  I quickly learned I needed the auto-immune protocol (and an IPad) and there was a huge lack of information available to learn more.  But I had hope again, I had something I could actually do to try and regain control of any kind, to regain health.  I could be proactive and this suits my type A personality really well.  J  I had already found through trial and error many of the foods I couldn’t eat and had been eating mostly paleo for years so the adjustments weren’t as overwhelming as for others perhaps.  Those little tidbits of the AIP were the pieces of information I didn’t know for sure.  I’d heard now and then to avoid nightshade vegetables or too much fruit but never knew why.  No offence meant to those who chose paleo for a belief in evolution or because they belong to Crossfit but that just didn’t cut it for me.  I needed a medical and scientific perspective to really grasp with full belief about the in and outs and why’s of it all.  That is when I came across our friend The Paleo Mom, and her blog and podcasts have been invaluable.  I’ve totally geeked out and print out her posts and pull out the highlighter and put them in a binder.  I sound exceptionally smart at my naturopaths office now, whereas before I was only moderately smart.  Her knowledge extends past what I could possibly have figured out on my own easily, her personal battle and continuing journey help when I feel alone and overwhelmed…because I’m not alone, and her dedication to help me and us is appreciated to the depths of my heart.  I’m not healed, I’m not even in remission, but I’ve made progress and I feel equipped to be a patient that stands up for myself.  I don’t expect overnight miracles after 20 years of this disease, but any regaining of living vs. being alive is a gift I’ll gladly accept.

My journey continues, and underneath all the symptoms and all the labels I’ve been falsely given, I’m still Jolaine.  The only way that can be taken from me is if I let it slip away and believe the lies and react to the ignorance as a personal affront.  People mean well, perhaps at least most of the time, but unless they live this journey they really can’t even begin imagine how difficult a road it is.  This part of my story is really only a small part.  There is much more on the personal and emotional side, and it’s the more painful part of the story.

If I learn only one thing from it all, it’s to be kind always to all people.  I try my best.  Everyone has a story and hurts so we can chose to add joy to their day, or be judgemental and rude.  Choose joy, for yourself and others, even on the hardest of days we must find joy.  For me today, I’m joyful I have flannel against my achy body, for tea and bone broth, and for a husband who loves me in sickness and in health and who still sees Jolaine.

Real People, Real Paleo—Jolaine’s Story (and how difficult getting an accurate diagnosis can be)

December 18, 2012 in Living with Autoimmune Disease, Real People, Real Paleo

“Real People, Real Paleo” is a series of posts written by real people who were inspired to share their paleo story with you.  There is such diversity in the challenges that bring us to a paleo diet and lifestyle and in what we hope to achieve by adopting them.  These stories are intended to be a place of inspiration, written by real people, showing the diversity of our needs and our approaches to this way of eating and living, and explaining how each individual’s implementation of paleo meets their needs.  By sharing these people’s stories with you on my blog, I hope to redefine what paleo success is.  I do not believe that eating paleo is purely about losing weight, gaining muscle, and having 6-pack abs.  I believe that paleo is about being healthy enough to thoroughly enjoy life, whatever that means for you, and about sustainability for our entire lives.  If you are interested in writing up your story, email me at thepaleomommy@gmail.com

So, I’m not in the habit of commenting on stories written for my Real People, Real Paleo series.  My preference is to let these stories speak for themselves.  But, I wanted introduce Jolaine’s Story with some amazing (and horrifying) statistics.  Autoimmune disease can be challenging to diagnose because it often presents as a collection of vague symptoms (such as fatigue, headaches, and muscle or joint aches).  Too often these symptoms are dismissed as signs of not getting enough rest, working too hard, life being too stressful, being over- or underweight, or our bodies just getting older.  What’s more, because there are no “autoimmune specialists”, we see doctors who don’t necessarily have the appropriate training to accurately diagnose these diseases (instead we see specialists in the organ or system that is showing the most symptoms).  A survey performed by the American Autoimmune and Related Diseases Association, Inc. (AARDA) showed that the majority of patients later diagnosed with serious autoimmune conditions had a difficult time obtaining a diagnosis.  In fact, 45 percent of these patients were labeled as hypochondriacs in the earliest stages of their illnesses.  Jolaine and I have had several back and forths via e-mail (and facebook and pinterest!) and I asked Jolaine to share her story because I believe it will resonate with many of you.  And I hope that by sharing Jolaine’s decades-long battles with undiagnosed autoimmune disease, that someone out there will have a lightbulb moment and will be armed with knowledge and confidence to request the right diagnostic tests from the right specialists and finally find their answers.

This is part 1 of 2.

I’ve had an auto-immune disorder for 20 years, but it took that long to get a diagnosis of Ankylosing Spondylitis along with the IBS, hypothyroid, and “unexplained” amenorrhea.  This journey has been incredibly difficult on so many levels, so much so that it’s hard to know where to start.  The logical place is the beginning, and I will focus on the exasperating quest for a diagnosis and help within the medical community.

I remember the beginning of my symptoms very clearly.  I was a newlywed and 21 years old, and had never given my health much thought, care or attention.  Up until that point in life I had a huge appetite and ate anything and everything in rather shocking quantities.  As an adult I was always around 100 pounds soaking wet and I never exercised regularly aside from being in Track and Field during high school.  At first all the random symptoms seemed mostly bothersome, but not of great concern.   On my honeymoon in Mexico I became very ill and learned later I had a parasite known as giardia.  I had no appetite, great fatigue, and intestinal distress.  My weight dropped considerably and I collapsed at my new job.  I took the prescribed medication and that was the end of my doctors’ suggestions for treatment, but I never really felt the same.  My tummy trouble continued and has never stopped.  Within about 6 months I started having shooting pain in my legs and hips and great difficulty walking.  I would take a bus ten blocks to work, go up the elevator and sit in my office where I wouldn’t move all day as much as it was possible.  It was then my journey with doctors of every kind started.

My first forms of treatment were to see a chiropractor, podiatrist, massage and physiotherapist.  I was twisted and turned, cracked and hung from my feet, electrodes attached all over me, heat and ice…and on and on.  None of this helped me at all.  I then eventually went to a rheumatologist who declared I had rheumatoid arthritis without one single test of any kind, only based on a 5 minute discussion.   I left with a prescription and never went back.  Another rheumatologist was referred by my GP and this time I was injected with radioactive dye and lay very still on a cold hard table, in a cold dark room, while a scanner went down my body following the dye as it travelled through me.  I remember this was a lonely and quite scary experience.  We trust doctors to do what’s best for us, and that no harm will come from the medicines and tests we undergo, but I wasn’t so sure this time.  The results of this test showed nothing.  By this time, I could barely walk at all, ever.

My husband and I made a move to another province and I started all over with new doctors. I remember very distinctly every morning before he left for work, my husband would pick me up and carry me to use the washroom, and put me back in bed where I’d stay most of the day.  I had been given the name of a chiropractor nearby who was apparently different from the rest and decided to give that a try, as I had no other options or ideas.  He did help and I started to see progress and able to walk again most of the time.  I carried on like that for many years, with times I was in excruciating pain, and other times I could walk just fine.  Sometimes even on the same day!  It was unexplainable to anyone, including myself.  I paid privately for an MRI and that also didn’t explain the mystery.  Simultaneously though more symptoms had begun, and the state of my health started to decline gradually.

I think I was around 26 years old when I stopped getting my cycle, and my tummy trouble was starting to get to the point where it affected my daily life in much more impactful ways.  I socialized less and less as it always involved great anxiety and in order to go anywhere for more than a few hours, I’d have to either not eat, or eat very little for a day or two prior.  This is zero fun for someone who has a huge appetite!   So in addition to my chiropractor and massage therapy, I was sent to a gastroenterologist, gynecologist, and endocrinologist.  The waiting period to see these specialists was often over a year.  Looking back I estimate I saw about four different gastroenterologists, three gynecologists, and two endocrinologists.  Going to appointments and tests was like a full time job, and doing it while feeling horrible and in tremendous pain was gruelling, and lonely.  The types of tests I had were often humiliating, painful, and downright disgusting.  I often felt like a little kid who had done something wrong, sitting on the other side of a desk watching a doctor tap his pen only to hear the most absurd comments and usually implying it was all in my head.  I also started seeking help from different naturopathic doctors as well, and this was very expensive and confusing for me because of the conflicting information between mainstream medical, and the alternative medical community.  It was around this time I had started reading everything I could get my hands on and started a quest to learn and be my own health advocate, to regain some control and power in my life in a time when everything felt completely out of my control.

If I think back to all the times I sat in a chair and listened to what a doctor had to say to me that was rude, mean, ridiculous, condescending, exasperating (you get the idea) I couldn’t possibly count.  Here is a very small example of those comments (summarized):

  • You want to bleed?  Is that the problem? Because I can do that.
  • Go home, sit on the couch for a good 6 months and eat pizza and get fat.
  • You are under a lot of stress and I think you need anti depressants?  Where is your stress coming from?  Is it your marriage?  Have you considered divorce?  Next time I see you I would like to see you making progress to filing for divorce.
  • We have an extra room in the hospital you could stay in.  It’s in the psych ward and you’ll be taken very good care of.
  • I think the best thing we can do is to cut everything out, your entire colon.  You could lead a very normal life after that.
  • That last doctor is a fool, don’t every see him again.
  • This is as good as it gets.  You are just going to have to manage.
  • I don’t know (at least that’s honest)
  • Read this book, and this book, and this book, breathe, be positive, do yoga, count your blessings, make a list.(not all bad advice, but not a solution either…I heard this as “it’s all in your head”)
  • There is no reason for you to be in pain.  Stop using those crutches and just walk.
  • You are faking this.  You are pushing out your tummy on purpose to look bloated. (at which point my generally quiet non-confrontational husband let out a string of expletives)
  • Just make up your mind and do it.  Get up and walk.  It’s mind over matter. Be positive.
  • I don’t know what there is to be stressed about.  You have a home, a husband, food on the table.  What cold possible cause you stress?  (um, well I can’t walk and it hurts, a lot)
  • Every time I see you, you have negative things to say.  Next time I want to hear only positive.
  • Aside from your hypothyroidism, your IBS, your Ankylosing Spondylitis and terrible fatigue, you are in excellent health!

This is off the top of my head but there are so many more.  Stress.  That’s the word that kept coming up over and over as the cause of it all.  In part that often made me feel like it was an easy answer for them to give and send me home, or it was my fault and within my control to change.  It felt like blame or that my condition was intentional.  When repeatedly asked very personal questions to pinpoint the cause of stress in my life, I repeatedly said it’s THIS….feeling horrible and pain is my biggest stress!!  I have actually been accused, more than once, of being a hypochondriac and a drama queen simply to get attention, from both doctors and “friends” and family.  I took it to heart though and learned all I could about stress and found it’s a fascinating topic actually.  The amount of damage stress can do to a body is remarkable, but most people only consider stress as things such as financial, relational, emotional stress etc, things that are quite easy to pinpoint and obvious.  To our body anything that raises cortisol is read as stress.  Too cold, too hot, hungry, tired, lack of nutrition rich food, pollution, noise etc.

I did see a few therapists over the years to help with the emotional toll it was taking on me.  The emotional aspect is a whole different aspect of being unwell for so long, but it’s huge.  Really, really huge.  For the most part I’d say for me, therapy didn’t help at all.  I don’t profess to be brilliant, but what I was being told was common sense to me, and did not equip me with tools I didn’t already know.  It was one of those therapists however who had recently taken an interest in brain waves and suggested I see a clinical psychoneurophysiologist.  A what?  Exactly.  I was desperate and just willing to try anything simply as a matter of just ticking things off that endless list of possibility.  So I went.  My husband would drive me to every appointment and I would lie in the back seat of the car curled up in a ball while he drove.  At the appointments I would sit in a chair with electrodes attached to my head, and sounds in my ears, in the dark.  None of it made a lot of sense to me, but I remained open minded and willing.  It cost thousands of dollars, and hey, if the waiting room is full it must be worthwhile right?

Five years ago, I accidentally and slowly overdosed on acetaminophen over a four month period during which I was completely immobile and in excruciating pain.  I had no help whatsoever, and despite my pleas for help, I was always sent home.  Perhaps they thought I was faking and just wanted good pain drugs, it’s hard to say for sure.  It was a very difficult and dark time in my life and I had no hope left.  I was exhausted, lonely, angry, and many of those long dark nights lying awake just trying to breathe, I didn’t care about being alive anymore.  There is a huge difference between being alive, and living.  I was merely alive.  After months of sleeplessness and mind numbing pain, I really didn’t care about how many pills I took, I just wanted relief.  I would take three Robaxacet every 4 hours, and often one Excedrin when I woke up with a terrible headache.  This was a symptom of the toxicity in my body from acetaminophen, but I was unaware of that.  I remember sitting on the edge of the bed with my husband holding an empty bottle.  I knew the day I bought it, and now it was empty.  A quick calculation and we knew it was way too much, but we didn’t fully understand the consequences and didn’t have an alternative either.  I remember saying “we need a different solution”.  It was only a day or two later that I was hospitalized.  In hindsight we could see I had started showing symptoms of overdose for a few days prior to hospitalization.  I was talking nonsense often and just not making sense at all.  I remember an argument we had when I was sure my best friend was in the bedroom and my husband was being too loud and going to wake her up.  I argued fiercely believing that to be true, but at some point I realized it wasn’t.  I didn’t understand what was happening, and went and hid in the bathroom and cried.  When he came in to find me I completely lost it and screamed and cursed at him at the top of my lungs fearing he would accuse me of being crazy, and honestly ashamed of being wrong.  This screaming and cursing is completely uncharacteristic for me, and I’m sure he was stunned, because I sure was.   From about this point on, I have no memory for about 4 or 5 days.  I only have the stories I’ve been told from those who were around me.  I was delusional and hallucinating, I was violent and cursing, I tried to escape the hospital and succeeded as far as getting down the stairs, I sat topless in the common area, ripped out my IV repetitively and tried to flush my pillow down the toilet.  My hands were tied down to my bed after I bit and kicked my husband while he tried to hold me down while I tried to escape.  At this point it became too much for him, and the nurses strapped my wrists to the bed for both of our safety.  They tested me for a brain tumour and honestly I don’t know what else; meanwhile giving me more and more drugs to add to the toxic pile up in my body.  When the liver tests came back they realized I had most likely overdosed on something and began to treat me.  My oldest sister flew from her home to sit by my bed day and night until they could get a 24 hour nurse/guard to be there.  A great big bag of supplements and pills and powders I was taking was brought into the pharmacy for analysis and to try and pinpoint what had happened.  The pharmacist was amazing and took a huge amount of time to find the manufacturer of every supplement, analyze the quality of the products and identify the contents.  It was a huge learning experience for me to learn the importance of buying quality and knowing where it comes from.  In only a few days I had lost all motor skills, I couldn’t control my bladder, I couldn’t talk for a swollen tongue, all the skin from the palms of my hands and fingertips would peel a layer or two every day as did my feet.   My mental fog was very slow to lift as was the whole recovery process. I often felt I was treated as a drug user for a very long time, or as someone who had intentionally attempted suicide.  Still to this day, I feel a label was placed on me that lasts.

About 3 years ago, I started seeing a different naturopath with great hope.  This of course meant another whole battery of testing, a change in my thyroid medication and other hormones, many supplements, 3x/week of colon hydrotherapy, much speculation, more money, more money, and still more money and I continue with this doctor today.  He was as baffled as all the other doctors, but we did make progress and for that reason I have continued as his patient.  Within two months, and after 13 years, I had my cycle back.  Admittedly this was not on the top of my list of things to fix, but it seemed miraculous!!  This didn’t solve the rest of my troubles, but it was a start.  I understand now how the gut is connected to what seems like every function in our body, hormones and inflammation included, and that was the beginning of where it all started for me.  When I think back to that parasite, on my honeymoon no less, it’s almost too much to realize how pivotal it was and how much it changed my life.  My current specialist recently said to me “There is a study done that shows if you happen to carry the gene HLAB27, and happen to travel to Mexico and happen to get giardia, 70% of those people get Ankylosing Spondilitis.  The parasite is the trigger that sets of the disease”.  When I told him all of that was true for me he merely said “oh”.  I wish we had just gone to Saskatchewan for our honeymoon instead!

During all these years I have continued with chiropractic up until a few years ago when I then had decided that physiotherapy using intramuscular stimulation was really my saving grace to help to walk.  Massage has also been a regular treatment.

The problem was, I still had no diagnosis.  I felt from family, friends, doctors and even strangers I shared with and even those I didn’t share with but would gossip behind my back, that it was all in my head.  People struggle to believe what they don’t see.  They lacked faith in my truth and that hurts more than any physical pain I endure.  My symptoms aren’t visible so therefore, I’m often treated with doubt.  I can’t even really verbalize the amount of emotional grief and injury that has brought to me, especially when it comes from those you call friends or family.

Don’t worry, that’s not the end of Jolaine’s Story.  Stay tuned for part 2 which will be posted on Thursday.

Guest Post by Dr. Laura Davies: Bringing Paleo to Your Doctor

December 11, 2012 in Overcoming Medical Dogma, Paleo Philosophy

 

Dr Laura Davies M.D. is a medical physician and PhD candidate in the field of neuroimmunology. She has been following paleo principles since May 2012 and has converted her family to this lifestyle with drastic improvements in all health markers. She is determined to help spread the paleo philosophy to the medical community in the hopes that we can significantly improve the health of all patients.

Many of you in the paleo community may feel exasperated by your physician. Whether they are a general practitioner or a specialist, it is highly likely that they have never heard of the paleo diet and are not aware of its benefits. This lack of knowledge can be frustrating for a patient who has made steps to improve their health by adopting this lifestyle, but is then told by their physician that “saturated fat is unhealthy”, “grains are an important part of the recommended diet”, “milk is necessary for strong bones” or insert any nutritional myth here that has been the standard recommendation. Your doctor’s intentions are good, but unfortunately their recommendations are based on what they were taught in medical school and what the official guidelines say (in particular the USDA food guide, which is far from what we know will bring us good health).

 If you find yourself in this situation, where your doctor is completely behind on the nutritional research, take advantage of the opportunity to spread the knowledge you have gained to your physician. The best way to do this is show them the significant progress you have made by following paleo lifestyle principles, whether that be blood pressure readings, improved blood glucose management, weight loss, decrease in skin/auto-immune flare-ups or any other marker of health. If your doctor sees the health improvements you have made, it may just inspire them to read more about it and maybe even apply it to other patients with similar conditions. If they are interested, you could recommend your favourite paleo book (I would recommend “Practical Paleo” by Diane Sanfilipo or “The Paleo Answer” by Dr Loren Cordain) or blog or podcast, where they could gather more information. You can also provide the references for scientific articles provided at the end of this post. The biggest mental obstacle for your doctor will be the amount of saturated fat in the paleo diet, as they have been taught since the 1960’s that saturated fat is bad for cardiac health. This has been proven false in the scientific literature, but this research has been slow to spread as this idea is so deeply entrenched. Ultimately, the paleo lifestyle is about eating real, whole foods, and minimizing toxins; a philosophy that is hard to argue with as a medical professional.

This is how I feel we will make real changes in nutritional recommendations; this is a bottom-up movement and by improving our health and showing our doctors just what can be done with proper nutrition, we will eventually make progress.

 If, on the other hand, your doctor is unwilling to work with you or accept your dietary wishes, then finding another doctor is necessary. It is important to have a doctor that listens to you, and works with you in a mutual relationship in order to come up with the most effective treatment plan for your medical issues. If this is not the case, it is time to move on. This, however, can be very difficult as there is a shortage of doctors, which is why I would initially recommend trying to work with your doctor. If you would like to find a paleo friendly physician, you have 3 options at the moment:

1.)

2.)

 

3.)    Networking with friends or through blogs to find information on doctors in your area.

I hope most of you have good relationships with your physicians, and need not worry about the issue; a good doctor-patient relationship can be such an important factor in finding the right treatment strategy for you.

Gluten:

Sapone, A. et al. Spectrum of gluten-related disorders: consensus on new nomenclature and classification. BMC Medicine. 2012 10:13.

Saturated fat:

 Mente A, et al. A systematic review of the evidence supporting a causal link between dietary factors and coronary heart disease. Arch Intern Med. 2009 Apr 13;169(7):659-69.

Siri-Tarino PW, et al. Meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies evaluating the association of saturated fat with cardiovascular disease. Am J Clin Nutr. 2010 Mar;91(3):535-46.

Paleo diet research:

Carrera-Bastos P, Fontes Villalba M, O’Keefe JH, Lindeberg S, Cordain L. The western diet and lifestyle and diseases of civilization. Res Rep Clin Cardiol 2011; 2: 215-235.

 Frassetto LA, Schloetter M, Mietus-Synder M, Morris RC, Sebastian A. Metabolic and physiologic improvements from consuming a paleolithic, hunter-gatherer type diet. Eur J Clin Nutr. 2009 Aug; 63(8):947-55.

 Cordain L. Saturated fat consumption in ancestral human diets: implications for contemporary intakes. In: Phytochemicals, Nutrient-Gene Interactions, Meskin MS, Bidlack WR, Randolph RK (Eds.), CRC Press (Taylor & Francis Group), 2006, pp. 115-126.