You May Have an Autoimmune Disease But Don’t Know It!

May 12, 2012 in Specific Autoimmune Diseases, The Autoimmune Protocol

Do you have an autoimmune disease that you are unaware of?  I’m not talking about the severe autoimmune diseases like lupus, multiple sclerosis, non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, and Grave’s Disease.  If you are unfortunate enough to suffer from one of these types of conditions, you are probably already aware that they are autoimmune in nature.  I’m talking about the conditions which are generally not life-threatening (although some of them can become so), for which the treatment may be as simple as a small dose of steroids or daily NSAIDS, and for which doctor’s typically shrug their shoulders like it’s no big deal.  Yes, a surprising number of those types of conditions, eczema and arthritis for example, are actually autoimmune in nature.

As I perused a list of confirmed and suspected autoimmune diseases, I was shocked by how many common skin conditions and gut health disorders are autoimmune in nature (to the point where I wonder if all digestive disorders and skin conditions will eventually be considered autoimmune diseases).  I was also surprised by how many autoimmune diseases are characterized by nebulous symptoms that could easily be ignored and attributed to not getting enough sleep (at least until they get bad enough).  Wikipedia has a comprehensive list of autoimmune diseases (here’s the link), but here are some that stood out to me as ones that many people suffer from without ever being told that they are actually autoimmune diseases (some of these are suspected autoimmune diseases rather than confirmed and some of them are certainly life-threatening serious diseases but maybe not commonly understood to be autoimmune in nature).

  • Alpopecia (spot baldness)
  • Arthritis (all forms)
  • Atopic Allergy (tendency to be hyperallergic)
  • Dermatitis (all forms)
  • Cancer
  • Type I Diabetes
  • Eczema
  • Endometriosis
  • Gastritis
  • Lichen Planus
  • Lichen Sclerosis
  • Morphea (localized scleroderma)
  • Myositis
  • Chronic Fatigue Syndrome
  • Narcolepsy
  • Polymyalgia rhematica
  • Psoriasis
  • Restless Leg Syndrome
  • Schizophrenia
  • Scleroderma
  • Vasculitis

It is worthy to note here that there is a whole other group of diseases, such as anxiety and depression, asthma, allergies, Type II Diabetes and even acne, that are not considered autoimmune disease but for which the immune system still plays a part.  If you suffer from any of these conditions, it is worth while giving strong consideration to following the paleo diet Autoimmunie Protocol, especially if out-of-the-box paleo doesn’t address your health issues. 

The more I read about health and nutrition, the more I am coming to believe that autoimmunity acquired as a result of a leaky gut caused by the Standard American Diet is far more rampant than epidemiological reports would have us believe.  I suspect that autoimmunity is a spectrum with symptoms so mild in the early phases that we are generally unaware.  I suspect that autoimmunity is very common is people with metabolic syndrome (or even people who simply struggle with weight loss).  And I think that in many people those ethereal early phases of autoimmunity can last years or even decades.  The symptoms of autoimmune conditions can be nebulous.  They can come and go and not seem to be anything more than the result of the stresses of normal life and what we consider to be a normal part of aging.  But if you find yourself claiming that “I’m just not getting enough sleep these days” or “yeah, my knees have been bugging me” or “well, my mom had arthritis at my age”, take a hard look at these symptoms and consider the possibility that you are perhaps dealing with the very beginnings of autoimmunity. 

Symptoms which may be caused by autoimmunity:

  • Extreme Fatigue
  • Muscle and Joint Pain
  • Muscle Weakness
  • Swollen Glans
  • Susceptibility to Infections
  • Sleep Disturbances
  • Unexplained Weight Changes
  • Resistance to Weight Loss
  • Yeast Infections
  • Digestive Problems
  • Anxiety and Depression
  • Migraines
  • Recurrent Headaches
  • Memory Problems
  • Allergies
  • Rashes
  • Blood Pressure Changes (usually low)
  • Low Blood Sugar
  • Thyroid Problems
  • PMS

When dealing with these early symptoms of autoimmunity, you are unlikely to get a clear diagnosis from your doctor.  But, you are more likely to see rapid resolution of your symptoms by following The Autoimmune Protocol (you may even see resolution of your symptoms with out-of-the-box paleo).  And on the very bright side, if you “catch it early”, you may be able to eventually reintroduce nuts, seeds, eggs, nightshades and alcohol.  So, are you a person who needs to follow The Autoimmune Protocol?  Maybe.  I would make this suggestion:  if you don’t feel amazing after a couple of months on out-of-the-box paleo, try The Autoimmune Protocol.  It just might be right for you.

Modifying Paleo for Autoimmune Conditions (i.e., The Autoimmune Protocol)

May 10, 2012 in Featured Posts, Paleo Modifications, The Autoimmune Protocol

NOTE:  This is no longer the most up-to-date version of the autoimmune protocol.  You can see the most current version here.

Autoimmune conditions and a leaky gut go hand in hand.  In fact, in every autoimmune condition that has been tested, a leaky gut is present and is a contributing factor to the illness (not all autoimmune conditions have been tested, but many in the paleo community assume that leaky gut is a factor in all autoimmune conditions).  For individuals with suspected or diagnosed autoimmune disease, additional dietary guidelines exist to help address the disease.  In many cases, autoimmune conditions can be put into full remission by following these guidelines.  There is some variability to these guidelines depending on who you ask, so I have reviewed them and compiled a comprehensive list of not only dietary restrictions but also food recommendations using information from The Paleo Solution, The Paleo Answer, and various podcast and YouTube interviews with Robb Wolf, Prof. Mat Lalonde and Dr. Terry Wahls (author of Food As Medicine and Minding My Mitochondria).  These are all great sources for more information.

It is vitally important to adhere to a strict paleo diet with no cheating.  While other people may be able to enjoy the occasional bowl of rice, if you suffer from an autoimmune condition you are not one of these people.  Grains and legumes should never be consumed.  Dairy of any kind (even grass-fed ghee which can still have trace lactose and dairy proteins!)  should be avoided initially (most people will not be able to successfully reintroduce dairy, although some will be okay with grass-fed butter and ghee).  This may be true for the rest of your life.  In addition, if you have an autoimmune condition, you should completely avoid:

The reason is that each of these causes gut irritation and/or increased gut permeability (and in the super sensitive gut of those with autoimmune conditions, they just aren’t tolerated).  There is also some evidence that hormonal birth control can contribute to hunger and digestive hormone disregulation, leading to inflammation.  However, you may wish to address the other elements in this post before going off birth control, depending on your personal circumstances.

Dr. Terry Wahls lays out a very convincing argument for increased vegetable intake.  Her focus is on eating vegetables from four main groups:  green veggies (for the vitamin B, A, C and K content and the mineral content), colorful veggies (for the flavonoids and polyphenols; at least 3 colors per day but this includes brightly colored fruit like berries), sulfur-rich veggies (cruciferous veggies, veggies from the onion family, mushrooms and asparagus), and iodine-rich foods (seaweed).  Dr. Wahls recommends eating 3 cups per day of each of green veggies, colorful veggies and sulfur-rich veggies as well as at least once serving per week of seaweed.  Note:  If you have Grave’s Disease or Hashimotos Thyroiditis, you must also avoid goitrogenic foods, which include raw cruciferous veggies, radishes, spinach, peaches, and strawberries (cooking reduces the goitrogens; fermentation increases them).  I also recommend an extra serving of seaweed each week as well as at least three servings per week of oily cold-water fish to support thyroid function  (except in the case of Hashimotos Thyroiditis as there are mixed reports of iodine taken either as a supplement or in iodine-rich foods actually worsening the disease).

Meat quality is very important as this profoundly impacts the types of fat that you consume.  It is extremely important to be mindful of your omega-3 to omega-6 fatty acid intake ratio, aiming for between 1:1 and 1:3, as this is essential for regulating inflammation in your body.  The best way to do this is to ensure that all of your meat, poultry and fish comes from grass-fed, pastured or wild sources. Oily cold-water fish (like salmon, mackerel, sardines, herring, kipper, anchovies, trout, fresh tuna, and carp) should be consumed at least three times per week for their high omega-3 content, easily absorbed protein, vitamin D and selenium content. Grass-fed meat also contains Conjugated Linoleic Acid (CLA), known to reduce inflammation, promote healing and even fight cancer.  The nutrient profile of pastured/wild meat and fish is superior as well.   My post on the importance of grass-fed meat contains some suggestions for incorporating it into your diet in a budget-conscious way.  It is also extremely helpful to incorporate organ meat into your diet at least twice per week due to its high nutrition density (including some amino acids, vitamins and minerals that are not as concentrated in muscle meats).  Note that the high vitamin A content of liver may be contraindicated in anyone consuming foods that they are allergic or sensitive/intolerant to as it has potential adjuvant activity (it may be better to add liver into the diet after 3-4 weeks of following this protocol).   It is also more important to eat organic produce as much as possible.  Whole9Life has a wonderful chart on when fruits and vegetables are in season including which fruits and vegetables are important to buy organic and which aren’t, if budget is an important concern.

Autoimmune conditions are also typically associated with disruption of normal gut microflora, often including Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth (SIBO).  For individuals with suspected or confirmed SIBO, avoidance of starches and sugars other than monosaccharides (like glucose and fructose) is very important (read my post Fruits and Starchy Vegetables with Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth for a list of which starchy vegetables are okay and which to avoid), although this is one aspect of the autoimmune protocol which is highly individual.  Some people do extremely well with the inclusion of starchy vegetables in their diet. For those with gut dysbiosis (any condition in which the type, amount or location gut bacteria are not normal), it is also important to help repopulate the gut microflora by eating raw fermented foods (like sauerkraut, coconut milk kefir, or kombucha) or taking a dairy-free probiotic supplement. Some people may need to avoid high FODMAP fruits and vegetables (which I discuss in this post) as FODMAP sensitivities are common in those with leaky guts and/or gut dysbiosis (when the lining of the gut is damaged, there tends to be fewer fructose transporters so any sugar or starch containing alot of fructose is harder to digest).  Others will need to limit themselves to cooked vegetables, which are typically easier to digest.

Healing the gut becomes very important.  I highly recommend consuming bone broth, organ meat (note the caution against consuming liver initially described above), oily fish, and coconut oil on a fairly routine basis as well as making sure that you are getting adequate vitamin D, whether you are taking a supplement, food sources like liver and fish, or spending lots of time outside. Note that coconut oil does not contain the phytic acid or inulin fiber (both gut irritants) that other coconut products contains (a little coconut is typically tolerated, but I urge caution).  Stress management is very important and I highly recommend doing at least one of the following: go for daily walks, take up yoga or tai chi, take a class on meditation, or make time for an activity/hobby that you absolutely love.  And I cannot emphasize enough the importance of getting lots of good quality sleep.  Aim for 8-10 hours of sleep in a cool, pitch-black room, preferably waking up without the use of an alarm.  It may help both stress hormone regulation and improve sleep quality to drastically reduce your caffeine intake.  Aim for no caffeine if you can.  It is also very helpful to drink plenty of water and to make sure you are consuming enough food.  The body is not very efficient at healing itself when you are running a caloric deficit (you shouldn’t have to gain weight to heal, but losing weight may be a competing goal for now).

I know from experience that this is a very challenging task.  I also know from experience that 90% is not good enough (and the more serious your condition, the more important compliance is).  I know from experience that this increases your food budget (although perhaps this can be negated by decreasing your medical expenses).  I try and focus on the delicious foods that I do get to eat.  I try and focus on the fact that I have a strategy for improving my health that is far more powerful than any prescription medication (Note that in many cases you will still need to be on prescription medications although you may be able to reduce your dose.  Please work with your doctor on this one!).  And, compliance gets easier once you start to see improvement.  Are these restrictions for ever?  Some may be and others might be successfully reintroduced after you see improvement in your symptoms. What foods you can reintroduce when if highly individual and will be the topic of a future post.

 

Modifying Paleo to Treat Psoriasis

April 19, 2012 in Sarah's Personal AI Struggles, Specific Autoimmune Diseases

In the paleo community, we are accustomed to assuming that a standard paleo diet will cure (or at least significantly improve) virtually every health problem.  But, if you have psoriasis (or dermatitis or eczema), be prepared:  paleo not only may fail to resolve these skin conditions, it might even make it worse.  Now, don’t go running for the hills.  The principles behind the paleo diet are still sound.  It is still the best way to eat for your long-term health.  And there are certainly some people who find complete resolution of their psoriasis symptoms with the switch to a paleo diet (for those people, the root cause of the psoriasis is typically a gluten sensitivity).  For me (and for many others), switching to paleo made my psoriasis worse.  This isn’t because paleo has us on the wrong track; it’s simply because out-of-the-box paleo is not actually enough. 

I am a long term sufferer of lichen planus, a form of psoriasis where the inflammation occurs in the mucosal layer of the skin (and very unnerving, you can actually get lesions in the gut mucosa as well!).  In fact, it was my search for a cause (and hopefully cure) for this condition that brought me to paleo in the first place!  All my other health issues either completely resolved or improved substantially within weeks of switching to a paleo diet, but my lichen planus did not improve.  If anything, it got worse.  But since paleo was working so well for me in every other respect, my search for a solution stayed within a paleo framework. 

What you might not know (and certainly I didn’t) was that psoriasis (and dermatitis and eczema) is an autoimmune disease.  It’s not always listed in those lists of autoimmune diseases that can be put into full remission by a paleo diet (it is listed in The Paleo Answer, but not The Paleo Diet nor The Paleo Solution).  Why is it so often left out?  I guess it’s because when compared to Lupus, Multiple Sclerosis or Non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, psoriasis is small potatoes.  And let’s just take a moment to appreciate how lucky we are that, when our bodies formed antibodies against our own cells, we only ended up with psoriasis! 

Psoriasis is also an indicator of a severely leaky gut (that’s how we develop the autoimmunity in the first place), with a very high likelihood of Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth.  It is also very commonly linked to a gut-brain connection problem with inflammation and autoimmunity targeting skin cells.  I went into some details about the gut-brain connection in this post, but I also recommend listening to the explanation of the gut-brain-skin axis that Chris Kresser gives in his Revolution Health Radio podcast episode titled “Naturally Get Rid Of Acne By Fixing Your Gut”.  There is a complex interplay between a leaky gut, a stressed body, loss of insulin and leptin sensitivity, mood issues, food sensitivities, and the inflammation that manifests as psoriasis.  Basically, if you suffer psoriasis, chances are your gut, your immune system and your hormones are all really messed up.  

So, what do you do about psoriasis?  The first and most important step is to follow the paleo diet “autoimmunity protocol”.  This means that in addition to all of the foods we already avoid while eating paleo, we must also avoid:

  • Eggs (especially the whites)
  • Nuts and Seeds (or at least severely restrict quantities)
  • Nightshades (tomatoes, eggplant, peppers of all kinds)

We are also people who Can Not CheatEver.  We can not tolerate any dairy, not even grass-fed butter or ghee.  Food quality becomes extremely important, so the more we can eat grass-fed meat, wild-caught fish, pastured eggs and chicken, and organic vegetables, the better (I know it’s expensive and I certainly can’t afford this 100%, but I just do the best I can).  And we are people who can’t tolerate very much sugar (even the sugars in fruits) or starches (even from superfoods like sweet potatoes) as they tend to feed the organisms in Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth.  It would be worthwhile to have a look at the GAPS diet food list as an indicator of which fruits and vegetables should be avoided (although I wouldn’t suggest starting with the GAPS diet protocol unless you really have tried everything else).  And that’s not all.  Because stress hormones can play a key role in the perpetuation of psoriasis, it is especially important for us to get lots and lots of high quality sleep, avoid excessive caffeine intake (or cut it out completely), severely limit alcohol consumption (or avoid it completely), get lots of low-strain exercise, manage the stress in our lives, get sun exposure and take a Vitamin D3 supplement (on the higher dose side; I take 12,000IU per day in addition to trying to get outside every day).  I also suggest reading my recommendations on Repairing The Gut.  In particular, I suggest incorporating organ meat into your diet at least twice per week, consuming bone broth or other collagen-rich foods (like gelatin, stew hens and heart meat) at least twice per week (every day would be even better), consuming fermented foods (like raw Sauerkraut or coconut milk kefir) every day, and consuming coconut oil every day (I like it in my coffee). 

So how long until you see some results?  You should start to see improvement very quickly, within a couple of days for some people up to 3-4 weeks for others.  If you do not see improvement within a month, you may also have developed additional food sensitivities (your gut is leaky, after all).  If doing all of the above still isn’t enough to see improvement in your symptoms, it would be worth finding a physician, naturopathic doctor, or chiropractor who will order an IgG and IgA food sensitivity blood test (you might also investigate Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth, internal yeast infections and parasite infections as possible confounding factors as well).  These food sensitivities are transient and once your gut has healed (and at least 6 months have passed without exposure), you should be able to reintroduce the foods.  Actually, you should be able to reintroduce eggs, nuts and seeds, higher sugar fruits and vegetables and maybe even nightshades at some point in the future as well.  Are you wondering how long this is going to take?  I’m afraid the answer is anywhere between 2 months and 2 years, depending on exactly what the root causes are for you.  But, if you could see how much my lichen planus has improved in 3½ months, you would be amazed.  I know that the extra dietary restrictions are tough, but it is worth it to be able to cure such an aggravating condition without the use of steroids.  And the thing to keep in mind is that once the psoriasis is gone, out-of-the-box paleo really will be enough for us.

 

Six Months of Paleo and Still Tweaking

February 23, 2012 in 2012

One of the things I love most about paleolithicnutrition is that it’s not a one-size-fits-all diet.  There are as many ways to implement paleolithic nutrition as there are people.  You can choose foods that you like; you can be more or less strict with gray-area foods depending on health issues; you can eat more carbohydrates orfewer depending on your fitness level and individual chemistry; you can eat paleo to lose weight; you can eat paleo to put on muscle; you can even eat paleo while also eating vegetarian.  I still feel like I’m tweaking my own implementation of paleolithic nutrition to completely address my own health challenges.  But, I do feel like I am finally honing in on what my body needs (and can handle).

If you read my New Year’s Resolutions post, you know that I have been following the autoimmunity protocol, which means no nuts, noseeds, no eggs, no caffeine, no alcohol, and no nightshades.  I am doing this because I am still struggling with a skin condition called lichen planus (a form of psoriasis).  I realize that while this is an autoimmune condition, it’s also a hallmark of Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth (SIBO) and Gut-Brain Connection problems.  So, I have changed a few things in my nutrition/health approach.

First, I am drinking coffee again.  I went 25 days without but my digestion got so sluggish without the stimulant effect of coffee that I was worried I was doing more harm than good.  I had Irritable Bowel Syndrome for 12 years and likely have some nerve damage as a result.  Coffee seems to be an important peristaltic stimulator for me (I’m trying to keep this dinner conversation level, folks!).  I am drinking about one third of the caffeine that I was before New Year’s, and it seems like a good dose for me (low enough to not mess with cortisol, high enough to have the desired effects on my digestion).  I missed coffee dreadfully, so I am very, very happy to have it back in my life (whipped with some grass-fed butter and extra virgin coconut oil—so yummy!).  I have also allowed myself some egg yolk (since the whites are the problem, not the yolk), and macadamia nuts (since they are low in phytates and in polyunsaturated fats). 

Second, I have a new focus on digestion.  I have started consuming 2 Tbsp of raw apple cider vinegar 10-15 minutes before my meals.  I am constantly reminding myself to chew my food thoroughly.  I am consuming a lot of ginger too (mostly hot ginger tea and homemade ginger kombucha).  I am a fermenting addict and now make my own sauerkraut, kombucha and coconut milk kefir.  I am also keeping starches extremely low (and other sugars fairly low as well).

Third, I am playing with intermittent fasting.  I will delve deeper into the benefits of intermittent fasting in a future post.  Intermittent fasting is where you don’t eat for 16-24 hours (its mostly important not to consume carbohydrates or protein) and this is also very customizable (how long, how often, how randomly, what you break your fast with, whether or not you consume fat during fast…).  I have chosen to skip breakfast but still have my two coffees with grass-fed butter and coconut oil (one when I get up in the morning and another a couple of hours later).  Normally, you aren’t supposed to fast if sleep or stress management aren’t perfect.  But I have found (in only a week playing with this) that I am sleeping better, feeling better and my mood is way, way better (well, I was a grumpy pants one day but my kids aren’t sleeping well and have been extra moody lately).  Also, I have seen faster improvement to my lichen planus in the last week than I did in the month and a half prior.  My plan is to try this maybe a couple of times each week, on random days, but generally on days when I don’t seem very hungry in the morning anyway (if you fast too often, it just becomes the way you eat, your body adapts and you don’t get the same benefits). 

The point of this post is to tell you two things.  First of all, my stricter version of paleo is working to address my health issues and this makes me VERY happy.  Second, a paleo diet is about lifelong health.  You can keep tweaking your own implementation of paleo until you have addressed your own health issues and achieved your goals.  You can further tweak your own implementation of paleo to stay there once you get there.  And I think that’s awesome.