Going Back to Cast-Iron

December 31, 2011 in Categories: by

Print Friendly

When I was a kid, the two most common cooking vessels used in our home were our cast iron frying pan and our wok. But then the low-fat diet revolution came.  And suddenly the amount of cooking fat typically used when cooking with cast-iron or stainless-steel was considered a major health risk.  So we, like so many families, switched to non-stick pans.  Teflon.  

Now remember the controversial statements made a few years ago by the EPA regarding the safety of one of the components of Teflon, perfluorooctanoic acid?  It is still unclear whether cooking with Teflon-coated cookware will increase your risk of cancer.  It seems as though non-stick cookware is safe as long as the cooking temperature is kept fairly low (below 260F) and the coating is intact (throw it out as soon as it starts to scratch or flake).  But, other than a few applications where that non-stick coating is magical, why not go back to those old tried-and-true cast-iron and stainless-steel pots and pans?  Especially now that we know that fat is not bad for you!  

Cooking with cast-iron is great.  A well-seasoned pan is just as slippery as its non-stick counterpart.  It heats evenly, can go in the oven, can be used at high temperatures, increases the iron content of our food, and has a very, very long lifetime.  And while high-end cast-iron cookware costs a pretty penny, a basic cast-iron frying pan is very inexpensive. (see for example, Lodge Logic L10SK3 12-Inch Pre-Seasoned Skillet)

Are you daunted by this whole “seasoning” business?  Yes, cast-iron cookware needs to be seasoned.  But, this isn’t a hard thing to do.  It basically means putting some fat in the pan and heating it in some way.  When you do this, the fat polymerizes on the surface of the pan and creates a non-stick coating.  You can season your pan with a variety of fats in a variety of ways, and of course, some work better than others.  I found a great blog posting on the science of seasoning cast-iron here.  While many people use saturated fat to season their pans, Sheryl Canter’s recommendation is to use flax oil (or another ALA-rich oil).  Place the pan in your oven and preheat to 200F.  Remove the pan from your oven (turn the oven off for now) and coat entirely with oil, inside and out.  Then, remove all excess oil with paper towel.  Put the pan back in the oven upside down and turn the oven on to 500F.  Once the oven has preheated, let the pan “bake” for 1 hour.   Turn the oven off and let the pan sit in there until the oven is cool (about 2 hours).  Don’t open the door before that point unless you want to fill your kitchen with toxic smoke.  With a new pan, repeat this process about six times before your first use.  After that, season as needed, anytime the surface starts to look dull or rusty.   

Washing your cast-iron pan is easy too as long as you do it while it’s still warm.  It’s best to use a gentle scrubber (think a brush or scouring pads instead of steel wool) and hot water.  Don’t use dish soap (if some special mess requires dish soap, you will have to season your pan again afterward).  If the pan is hard to wash, it probably needs to be seasoned again.

Truly, there are few things in a kitchen as beautiful as the shiny black color of a well-seasoned cast-iron pan.  And while, I still use my non-stick pan for some purposes (cooking anything salty, like bacon or sausage, can be pretty rough on a cast-iron frying pan), I feel as though I have discovered a new love:  a love of cooking with my cast-iron frying pan.


I realize this is a pretty old post, but I stumbled across it simply because I *love* cooking with cast iron. When it comes to getting a good meat sear or a nice crust on baked goods, nothing compares to it.

Besides using bare cast iron, I also use Le Creuset’s enameled cast iron products. I have tried Lodge’s enameled cast iron with little success; the enamel deteriorates over time. The heavy weight and even heat distribution ensure my stocks and sauces don’t burn at the bottom or cook unevenly (especially when using thickeners).

Another type of iron pan many Americans seem unaware of is French iron pans. The main manufacturers are Mauviel and De Buyer. I personally find them much easier to deal with than cast iron. I discovered them when I was reading Julia Child’s Mastering the Art of French Cooking (still my #1 recipe source even though I’m Paleo).

Below is the one I use for making omelettes. They also make fantastic crepe pans (well they *are* French). I’m a fan of the larger frying pan as well.


What are your thoughts on the “Green pan”? It’s marketed as safe, but do we know that it is or what it’s made of? I use it for eggs, but not sure if it’s a good idea. Thanks!

I’m in need of a new skillet and trying to decide if cast iron is the way I should go. I use my skillet mostly to fry or scramble eggs, brown ground beef or sausage, cook chicken apple sausage patties, or sauté veggies. Would cast iron work well for all those things? Or should I try to find a good non stick skillet?

Now may I just say, using flax oil STINKS UP the whole house like hell and set off the fire alarm at midnight when I decided to try seasoning my pan.
Coconut oil would be much better, I am sure, but DO NOT use flax oil unless you want trouble.

I’m wondering about the toxic smoke part. Why would the smoke from a flax seasoned cast iron pan be toxic? Flax will go rancid if heated, so it wouldnt be my choice of seasoning oils, I believe coconut oil is the only plant oil thats safe to heat

We use coconut oil or plain old crisco to do ours. Currently we’re without an oven(not one in the studio apartment) so I season as best I can over a hot plate.

What is suggested with a new, pre-seasoned Cast iron skillet if I’m AIP with some reintroductions? Should I strip the seasoning already on it and season myself or just season it myself with AIP safe oil (such as coconut oil or lard) over whatever it is pre-seasoned with? If I strip the seasoning, what’s that process? Thank you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *