How Mood and Gut Health Are Linked
February 11, 2012 in Beyond Paleo, Gut Health
One of the challenges that I face personally with my health is something called the Gut-Brain Connection (or sometimes called the Gut-Brain Axis). Basically, brain health affects gut health affects brain health affects gut health. It’s an idea that has been around in the scientific literature for decades (at least seven of them!), but has yet to pervade medical practice (like so many nutrition-related health issues). I have been really interested in this topic for a while now and I thought it was time that I shared some of this information with you. I know this is ALOT of information, so please feel free to comment with any questions (or skip to the salient points , which are italicized or bolded).
The entire gut is lined by an extensive network of neurons embedded directly into the walls of our esophagus, stomach, intestines, rectum and colon. This is called the enteric nervous system, which consists of more neurons than in either the spinal cord or the peripheral nervous system. This network of neurons is so extensive, that it has been coined the “Second Brain”. It has the very important job regulating all the various aspects of digestion, from breaking down food, to absorbing nutrients, to expelling waste.
It may not be surprising that the brain has a direct effect on the digestive system. For example, thinking about food can release digestive enzymes into the stomach before you even eat. If you’re nervous or stressed, your stomach may feel upset. But how does this work?
- Your brain sends signals to all of the nerves in your body. These signals are essential for everything from breathing to moving your legs so you can walk. A very large portion of your brain’s output is directed into the vagus nerve, the nerve which innervates (which means branches into the nerves controlling) most of the thoracic (chest) and abdominal cavities. The vagus nerve thus controls a wide variety of functions, from your heart beating, to the secretion of digestive enzymes, to the peristalsis of your intestines. The important part here though, is that the vagus nerve innervates the digestive tract.
- Stress, anxiety, depression and strong negative emotions decrease your brain activity, which decreases activation of the vagus nerve. This will reduce pancreatic enzyme secretion and cause poor gallbladder function, thereby reducing stomach acid production, as well as decrease gut motility, decrease intestinal blood flow, and suppress the intestinal immune system.
- When this reduced vagus nerve activation is persistent, the slowing down of so many digestive functions results in something called Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth (SIBO), an increased growth of pathogenic yeast and bacteria in the gut (specifically the small intestine, the longest section of our intestine responsible for nearly all digestion). These are not the beneficial bacteria that we are supposed to have lower down in our digestive tract.
- These “bad” yeast and bacteria (which are also too high up) contribute to an increase in intestinal permeability (a.k.a. leaky gut) beyond what is already caused by the lectins and saponins in dietary grains and legumes. Even in the absence of dietary grains and legumes, SIBO can cause a sufficiently leaky gut to produce systemic, chronic low grade inflammation. This effect of the brain on the gut is why people who suffer depression so often also have constipation or suffer from Irritable Bowel Syndrome.
I know this is dense, but the basic point is that stress, anxiety and depression result in a leaky gut.
What you might not already know is that the gut has a direct effect on the brain. A troubled intestine can send signals to the brain, just as a troubled brain can send signals to the gut.
- Actually, about 90 percent of the fibers in the vagus nerve carry information from the gut to the brain and not the other way around. There is scientific evidence to suggest that the gut can communicate directly with the brain, perhaps having a direct impact on emotions and moods via the nervous system.
- Better understood though, are the chemical signals that are sent to the brain from the irritated/damaged gut. When the gut becomes leaky and inflamed, the inflammatory cytokines (chemical signals of inflammation) that are produced in the gut travel through the blood to the brain.
- These inflammatory cytokines cross the blood-brain barrier and activate the resident immune cells of your brain, the microglial cells. Yes, this is exactly what it sounds like: a leaky gut causes body-wide inflammation, including inflammation in the brain.
Now, for the vicious circle part: an inflamed brain has decreased nerve conductance which manifests as stress, depression and/or anxiety.






































This is such a great post! My husband suffers from chronic anxiety and I’m trying to get him to eat paleo. He sure misses pizza though. Anyway, I love this site and the posts on organ meats were really informative. I’m going to have beef heart for dinner!
Also, just because I couldn’t resist: http://hyperboleandahalf.blogspot.ca/2010/04/alot-is-better-than-you-at-everything.html
This is my blog, http://diabeticpaleo.wordpress.com/
I’m working on a paleo pizza recipe for my family (I still can’t eat nightshades and it just doesn’t taste like pizza without tomato sauce). Once I have it worked out, I will definitely share!
And yes, I use alot, er, alot. But a lot is not grammatically correct either. So I just roll with it.
Have you tried a chicken/bacon/ranch pizza? That’s one of my favorite kinds and I have been making that for my kids, who are off nightshades. They chow down on it and love it. My crust though, is a non-Paleo, gluten-free store-bought crust mix (free of the top 8 allergens), that I use for the sake of convenience and lack of other ideas.
Do you have any thoughts on whether a vagus nerve that is overstimulated can also be causing a leaky gut? My 2-yr old gets so mad sometimes that he passes out. It’s not a holding his breath long enough to pass out. The pediatrician wasn’t concerned, but after it happened 5 times one weekend, we took him back to the doctor and to a chiropractor. Both agreed that it was an over-stimulation of the vagus nerve causing him to pass out. Once he passes out, the stimulation stops, and normal operation returns. He has not had any episodes since we started chiropractic adjustments, until last week when he had 1.
I believe it is possible. Overstimulation of the vagus nerve could speed up peristalsis so less nutrients are absorbed, potentially leading to gut irritation. Also, the adrenalin and cortisol released when your son gets so mad might have an effect on inflammation in general. I wonder what is causing the overstimulation in the first place. Do you have him on a strict paleo diet? I would guess that doing what you can to reduce inflammation won’t hurt anything.
Great points and questions. The kids have been on an elimination diet since last September to try to eliminate constant dark circles under their eyes (worse on the 5-yr old than the 2-yr old). At first we cut out gluten, dairy, eggs, soy, corn, peanuts, and nuts. Without all that (eggs and nuts especially), it was hard to be completely Paleo, especially for snacks at school. So, they ate some processed food made with rice flour, rice syrup, regular sugar, etc. Not ideal, but it kept me sane. Enjoy Life granola bars were a staple (not so much anymore as they are high in sugar). Around Christmas time, I added back in eggs and nuts, one kind at a time. Most recently (about a month ago), we pulled out nightshades. My reading lately (a lot from your blog, Chris Kresser, Balanced Bites, etc) has made me think that I need to go back and pull out the eggs and nuts again, and be more strict about rice, seeds, etc while also trying to include more coconut oil, bone broth, and healing foods. My 5 yr old has very low SIGA values, so we are trying to get that straightened out as well.
the fact that chiropractor is mentioned without any contesting greatly reduces the weight of this post and blog. paleo diet is sound science, chiropractory is not.
I also just bought some kefir grains that I am going to use for coconut milk kefir and yogurt. I am trying to find more ways to get good bugs into their systems in addition to a probiotic supplement.
With low SIgA, I think you are absolutely on the right track with cutting out eggs and nuts again as well as increasing probiotics and healing foods. Have you seen my post on Kid Snacks yet? No nuts and eggs makes it harder, but it’s not impossible. These days my 5-year old is really into grass-fed hot dogs (I buy applegate ones but grasslandbeef.com also sells them for about the same price) with some fruit on the side. I hope you can get everything figured out!
Yes, I saw your snack post which was great as always. As for hot dogs, I haven’t found any that don’t have paprika or peppers (nightshades) in them. I definitely miss having that option for my kids, even if we only ate them only once every week or two. I’ve found some lunch meat with acceptable ingredients, and while not grass fed, I’ve been using it on occasison. It looks like Applegate’s lunch meat would be better. I’ll have to see if I can find that anywhere.
Yes, I don’t know of any hotdogs that are nightshade free (I keep forgetting about paprika, that sneaky little spice). Have you checked out some of the other convenience meats from grasslandbeef.com?
This is a really helpful post. Much has been written about the physical/chemical issues of paleo but the mind-body connection is so critical, especially in terms of how the subconscious is in charge of all of our thousands of processes of physiological metabolism.
A great new book I recently came across on this subject is “Code to Joy” by George Pratt, which really addresses how you go about aligning how your brain processes and operates in a more “paleo” way. The author presents a really simple but very effective 4-step process of healing that so reminds me of the paleo process for restoring the body: identify cognitive issues, clear, re-pattern (renew), and anchor. I hardly ever recommend books but this book is especially enlightening and helpful.
Thanks! I will check it out.
[...] disaccharides like sucrose are off limits. I have touched on this subject in a couple of posts (How Mood and Gut Health Are Linked, Repairing The Gut, and most recently, Modifying Paleo to Treat Psoriasis), but I felt like further [...]
[...] How mood and gut health are linked [...]
Amazing post!!!!
Thanks Paleomom for an excellent post. On the paleo anti-inflammation diet you restrict nuts. I’m curious about whether soaked nuts are less inflammatory? Since the inhibitors are removed by soaking, it just seems to me they would be easier on the gut. I’m new to the site, so you may have already answered that question.
Thanks, Bill.
They are less problematic when soaked, but there are still potential issues with them. So, i suggest trying it and seeing how if affects you. I know that for me, it doesn’t matter, it still doesn’t work for me.